Against the Motion
Sara Labib
Introduction
“Knowledge is a tool, and like all tools, its impact is in the hands of the user”. (Brown, 2019). We exist in a heavily digitalized era, where technology is a tool that we can no longer forsake. And rightly so, because thanks to this technological advancement, we are able to reach new highs that we never dared dream of. Vast seas of knowledge are a click of a button away, and the interest, is now a hub for new and bright ideas. We are now able to share and gather information in the easiest way possible and not only have we reached the peak of communication, but we have also gone as far as to use this tool to make us even more literate. Electronic media should be considered the number one contributor to the increased literacy rate amongst human beings in the digital age. The motion of whether electronic media are making us more or less illiterate is heavily debatable, however, there are many factors that tip the scale in the benefit of electronic media.
​
Linguistic Instability
According to research conducted by the Utrecht Institute of Linguistics on the matter of “Language Structure: Variation and Change”, researchers were able to conclude that “Languages change over time. As a result, linguistic properties need not be stable” (“Language Structure: Variation and Change”, 2018). The conclusion that language is not a stable or fixed matter aids in abolishing the argument that today’s electronic media is making us more less literate, while many would argue that the use of slang and abbreviations in today’s mediated messages is only leading us towards illiteracy, I would argue that it is leading us to find newer and easier ways to communicate our thoughts in a free online space. In this time and age, people are rushed, busy and in a constant hurry to get things done; Eric J. Fox writes in his online article “People around the world are moving so fast, trying to do so much, that humanity as a whole is slowly choking itself with its own progress” (Fox, 2008). And the sole purpose of electronic media is to make life easier for individuals. This type of instant gratification is due to the accelerated pace of CMC (computer mediated communication) and language is in fact, changing over time to suit the needs of this fast-paced generation. Therefore, the surfacing of such linguistic changes should not be considered a factor in making people illiterate.
​
Internet Slang and Emoticons
The internet is considered a safe haven for creation. It consists of slang words, abbreviations, and acronyms that online users have created in order to make for a smoother and easier communication process. Instead of considering elements such as internet slang and abbreviations a form illiteracy, it is more reasonable to consider them a creative answer to this generation’s needs and wants. Take for a moment, the existence of dialects into consideration. For instance, according to the Arab Academy, there are eleven basic Arabic dialects that derived from the original Standard Arabic (“Which Dialect Should A Non-Native Arabic Learner Study?”, 2018). Similarly, it would make sense to consider Internet slang a dialect of its own as it, too, is used by the internet community. Seeing as main purpose of language is to communicate, and it is safe to say that a message can be relayed in several different forms but still hold the same meaning. Acronyms and abbreviations have surfaced from different sources such as chatrooms, emails and most importantly, cell phone text messaging. Websites such as noslang.com offer a full dictionary of internet slang, some of the most frequently used terms would be “LOL” for “laughing out loud”, “WBU” which stands for “what about you?”, “TBH” which stands for “to be honest” and “OMW” which stands for “on my way”. These acronyms get the message across in a simple and easy manner, without requiring an individual to type long sentences in case they are rushed or preoccupied. “Another thing common to internet
communication is the truncation and morphing of words to more typing-friendly forms. These may one day creep into common usage and end up in the dictionary.” The use of abbreviations to reduce keystrokes can be illustrated through terms such as “noob” which is an abbreviation for the word newbie used to describe a person who is unfamiliar with a certain topic or in gaming terms considered an amateur. While some would argue that people who use abbreviations are less intelligent and therefore choose not to type full sentences, research shows that the use of internet slang may be making individuals more intelligent, or in any case, it does not appear to be making anyone less intelligent. According to Montreal-based linguist Gretchen McCulloch, “Several studies show that people who use a lot of internet abbreviations perform, at worst, just as well on spelling tests, formal essays, and other measures of literacy as people who never use abbreviations — and sometimes even better.” (McCulloch, 2019).
​
Electronic media, more specifically, social media, has become a bridge between cultures. Information being shared on social platforms allows for the creation of new terms and slang as a result of cultural integration, such terms are helping individuals creatively express their thoughts and feelings. Not to mention, that several terms can now be traced back to a certain ethnic or social group. To illustrate, slang terms such as “spill the tea” originated from African-Americans who use it to describe the process of gossiping or giving out information. Other terms such as “ghosted” is used to describe the process of having someone suddenly cut off all contact with another individual without previous warning. Furthermore, it is important to take into consideration social platforms such as twitter, which allows users to create messages that consist of one hundred and forty characters only. Such platforms encourage creativity and literacy seeing as the word number is very limited, one must be very creative and careful with their choice of wording in order to ensure that they’re articulating their thoughts in the best way possible.
​
A major concern the opposing team might raise is “ how would we be able to interpret social cues with a medium like electronic media?” while some would argue that electronic media makes it harder to get the message across due to the fact that electronic media makes it difficult to interpret social cues and leave a lot of space for miscommunication, I would argue that with technological advancement, we are now able to easily transfer said cues to the digital space. To demonstrate, let’s take into consideration the creation of emoticons, more commonly known as “emojis”. In the International Communication Association’s research article on “Expressing Emotions Online: An Analysis of Visual Aspects of Emoticons” it states that emotional icons, are visual representations of facial expressions used in CMC to indicate the mood and/or emotion of a user.” The use of emoticons can now arguably substitute CMC and thus enhance one’s understanding of the message. Some of the most frequently used emoticons are the smiley face emoji “ ” and the sad face emoji “ ” which indicate two of the most basic emotions known to mankind, however, now there is a wide set of emoticons available for every feeling known to man.
​
Moreover, the fact that social media platforms allow people to form online friendships with individuals from different backgrounds means that electronic media works as window to cultures beyond our own therefore exposing people to new ideologies, beliefs and knowledge.
An interesting study done by Masaki Yuki of Hokkaido University concluded that emotions are interpreted based on the most expressive part of the face which differs from one country from another. For instance, this study provided us with an example that compare the United Stated and Japan in terms of emoji use. In the study, researchers noted that the Japanese use “^_^” to illustrate happiness, take into account the expressive eyes and the more neutral mouth while Americans tend to use “ : )” which has a more expressive mouth and set of very dull and neutral eyes; that specific use of symbols is due to the fact that the Japanese find the most expressive part of the face to be the eyes contrary to the American belief that the mouth is the most expressive facial part. This study further proves that electronic media help us in better understanding different cultures and their ways of expression thus making us more literate.
​
​In addition to the use of emojis, we are now able to identify certain tones using words and typing. According to Patricia Rockwell’s research study, “Yeah, right!: A Linguistic Analysis of Self-reported Sarcastic Messages and Their Contexts” most if not all forms of sarcasm rely on a person’s tone of voice. But how can one relay a tone of voice through words? The most common way to do that would be by italicizing the word to indicate that it should be read in a sarcastic tone. For example:
Person A: Sara told me the festival was fun.
Person B: Yeah right, tons of fun.
​
The employment of italicization in the previous statement insinuates that it was a sarcastic statement. This is one of the many wonders on online communication that users came up with in order to better understand each other.
​
Learning Tool
Bearing in mind the most basic definition of literacy which is defined as “the ability to read and write” according to the Cambridge English Dictionary, it is crucial to take into consideration the ways in which electronic media contribute to the outspread of knowledge and dissemination of information. Nowadays, we see young children using electronic devices and learning how to speak and write the alphabet simply as a result of watching YouTube videos. Electronic media is at the end of the day, a mere tool. Utilizing it to teach generations is the best way of putting it to good use, some would argue that traditional means of learning are better for children, as it is the way they were taught, and the way their parents were taught and so on. But times change, and human being are expected to evolve and keep up with the demands of this day and age. The features available through electronic media actually prove to make the learning process not only easier but way more entertaining making the information easier to digest, some of the merits of electronic media are “Access to the cloud – where students can store information, download links that include audio and visual illustration.” (Weiner, 2014). There are several online services and apps that help individuals learn new languages, for instance “Duolingo” is an infamous app used by 30 million people worldwide that allows users to learn new languages as it teaches speaking, reading and writing skills. there are more people actively learning a language through “Duolingo” than in the entire US public school system," says Luis von Ahn, we therefore conclude that electronic media is in fact, helping us become more literate. In addition, the “Uses and Gratifications Theory” comes into play here, where individuals seek certain information to satisfy certain needs (Katz, 1973). To incorporate it into the context of electronic media in regard to literacy, individuals could utilize this tool to seek out information that helps them become more literate.
​
Critical Consciousness
Bearing in mind the less traditional definition of literacy which according to the Oxford English Dictionary is “having education or knowledge, typically in a specified area, the way electronic media contributes to bettering the process of gathering and soaking in knowledge becomes of more prominence. Electronic media admittedly makes gathering information much easier considering the abundance of educational platforms available, but it also contributed to the dissemination of information. Thoughts are easily voiced and more easily shared, making electronic media the channel through which people establish different learning hubs. This generation now has the term “media literacy” down to a T seeing as the comprehension of media is considered second nature, not something that has to be taught.
​
Paulo Freire’s definition of “critical consciousness” can be used in the context of electronic media and literacy. Critical consciousness, also known as “conscientization” is a concept developed by Paulo Freire which is generally defined as “the ability to intervene in reality in order to change it”. Conscientization can be understood as the process of engaging and implementing theories to fully understand how they play out in reality; it heavily depends on the act of reflection as a mean to get to the point of self-awareness; specifically, the awareness of oppression. “None are more hopelessly enslaved than those who falsely believe they are free” (Goethe, 1809). We believe that we are free, but the truth is we are oppressed in more ways than one. Electronic media helps one realize that we merely have the illusion of freedom, the decisions we make are not really our own; we are primed to make certain choices and think certain thoughts. For instance, we believe our opinions are our own, but the carefully selected messages displayed on the media and in the news are really directing our opinions to a certain path. Not to mention, one would think that now, in the 21st century, problems such as racism and sexism would be long gone simply because people of color are not in chains anymore, but they’re still being discriminated against. According to a study conducted by PayScale on employee referrals, black men are 26% less likely to get a referral than white men (Gruver, 2019). We are way farther from freedom than we think, a Syrian in 2019 is only allowed visa free access to 29 countries in the world (“Henley Passport Index, 2019), when a piece of paper derives one of access to the world they are entitled to that is when we realize that freedom is simply an illusion, not a reality. Electronic media raises awareness on this issue, movements such as “black lives matter” were raised on social media platforms, also, it is important to consider how easily spread information is using electronic media; a single tweet or blog post by an aware individual could open the eyes of thousands of blinded people. In other words, the process of critical consciousness leads individuals to the realization that they are puppets in someone else’s show, or according to Arlene Goldbard, “object" of others’ will rather than a self-determining “subject.” (Goldbard, 2006).
​
Critical consciousness can be applied to all areas of life, especially in the context of electronic media. Nowadays, media can either lead individuals to self-awareness or stray them farther from it. Electronic media has intervened in reality and created what can arguably be the biggest change in the world. It revolutionized areas of communication, information, social relations and even contributed to economic growth, political movement. These changes had a tremendous effect on the world at large, and this surge of change birthed doubt as older generations who are less accepting of technology and less adaptive to the changes of the world argued that electronic media is a boon rather than a bane and raised debates on whether or not this new era of advancement was wholly beneficial or wholly corrupt; therefore leading us to reflect on our media usage, the content we create and more importantly, the content we consume. We began to weigh the pros and cons in order to reach a consensus, such reflection aids us in becoming self-aware of the choices we make and their effects on us. While media literacy is the way
we analyze mediated messages, but critical consciousness determines how we react to these messages. Let’s take for example advertisements for certain products such as iPhones and Androids; iPhone advertisements make them look more appealing and luxurious, a product for the elite especially because they come with a hefty price tag and are considered “cool” by this generation. Someone who is critically conscious would be able to decipher that advertisement for what it is, the advertisement of a lifestyle rather than the actual product and opt for the more efficient and effective Android phone which is just as smart as an iPhone and not as expensive because a critically conscious human being would not buy into the stereotype of what’s in trend and would not care much for appearances.
​
Whether we use electronic media in order to benefit from it and become more knowledgeable and educated individuals by consuming educational content, reading online articles and exploring the various research material provided online or abusing it in a way that leaves us void of benefit through absorbing useless material such as pornographic videos, gaming sites that encourage violence and following insipid social trends that do not contribute to broadening one’s mind, is a decision that lies solely in our hands. Electronic media caters to all of its users and their inhibitions, good or bad. It is critical consciousness that determines how we electronic media to affect our daily lives.
In conclusion, electronic media are making us more literate due to the fact that they are a learning tool as well as a communication tool. Not to mentions, that electronic media are allowing the free flow of creative concepts and linguistic evolution. It is of upmost importance to remember, that electronic media remains a tool to be controlled. And it is our job to make sure that it is taken advantage of in the right manner.
Abdullah Al Hadi
Introduction
I am debating against the motion of the debate topic which is: are electronic media making us more or less literate. This era is a technological, advanced, and an era that depends highly on electronic media. Today’s world became much closer because of enhancements in electronic media. “Electronic media: is the media that one can share on any electronic device for the audiences viewing (Carl Xie-Connell, 2015)”. Examples on electronic media include viewing media content on YouTube, Snapchat, and reading an article on the internet. For instance, Electronic media are things such as: socializing on social media. How many new ideas and words did people grasp or understand from electronic media? In this research these points will be highlighted: 1. What is the literacy in relation to electronic media. 2. Questions in relation to Erudite debate team, and our position. 3. The relation and implementation of technology and media in universities. 3. Ways of electronic media making us more literate. 4. Counterargument of our motion. What will make the research significant is the solid arguments and reasons of electronic media making us more literate.
​
What is literacy in relation to electronic media?
In her book "The Literacy Wars," Ilana Snyder argues that "there is no single, correct view of literacy that would be universally accepted. (Nordquist, 2019)”. Any literate person must try to contribute effectively to human knowledge and analyze content accurately. When we open any electronic media platform in average how many words do individuals read? For example, people can open Snapchat on their phones, and they will definitely open three-four contents and they will definitely read words. Even in any picture if individuals don’t read words, they have to have the skills to analyze, and to differentiate reality from fake news. For example, one form of literacy can be participating in effective health campaigns, and not smoking, this is how and what differentiates a literate person, he/she must measure the incentives, benefits, and harms they will get from smoking. Synder et al. (2004).” “Mobile Devices Can Dramatically Improve Literacy Rates in Developing Countries, Says UNESCO, A new report by UNESCO says that mobile devices can boost literacy rates in developing countries, potentially
reaching almost all of the world’s population. Furthermore, an expensive tablet or smartphone is not necessary. In fact, many e-book readers use featurephones (Shu, 2014)”.
​
Questions in relation to Erudite debate team, and our position
Some students use electronic media daily, and according to Zephoria website “Daily Active Users of Twitter (annual) growth has increased by 11 percent for 2019. “Top 10 Twitter Statistics – Updated October 2019” (n.d.) describes how Twitter active users in 2019 increased. Why do some people that neither attended schools nor universities are able to write, talk, and analyze better than some educated people? This occurred because of electronic media, for instance you can never get educated but for example, when you watch basic English videos then you instantly learn English. Why are some schools and universities focusing on education techniques that are based on electronic media such as tablets, computers, and smart devices? For example, in CUD public relations student’s took courses that rely on computers which are devices, such as publication design courses. At the University of Southern California, Nina Eliasoph’s Sociology 250 syllabus reads: “You must check e-mail DAILY every weekday,” with boldface for emphasis (Rubin, 2013). This shows that usage of technology increased in several universities. Youth prefer classroom environments that resemble the way they use digital tools at home (Project Tomorrow, 2014)”. Can you conduct a quantitative research without using SPSS and Excel software’s or any other software to show your results and analyze them? Some banks shifted to online banking such as Monzo Bank in England, this bank doesn’t have any branch. We can conduct a full research now with electronic books, blogs, and articles. We don’t necessarily need any print media content to conduct an accurate and solid research.
​
The relation and implementation of technology and media in universities
Some of smart and technological universities examples include: Sheikh Hamdan Bin Mohammed Smart University. Some artificial intelligence and smart fields are artificial intelligence and smart cities field in American University of Sharjah. Their research depends on online databases also, and they use online platforms to submit work, and communicate with their professors. This is relevant to the topic because when people learn online, then they use an electronic device to see the professor, and to see assignments, or you use electronic media platform such as Moodle or Blackboard to send the researches. “The Independent becomes the first national newspaper to embrace a global, digital-only future (The independent, 2016)”. This shows the relationship between technology which is shifting online, and media content which is the newspaper, the relation to the topic is that several newspapers which are needed for analysis, resources in a media student’s life, and are essential in research as effective sources are used daily in universities. For example, a lot of individuals use the Independent online articles several times in research and for reading to enhance their skills.
Ways of electronic media making people more literate
Electronic media essentially makes us more literate because when you use any media platform you mostly see contents. “BBC Learning English is a (famous) Instagram account with over 1.4 million followers. They regularly post quick quizzes and grammar cards, explain phrases. Even better, they create videos so that you can (enhance) your pronunciation and learn new vocabulary around a theme Find them at @bbclearningenglish (Brenda, 2019).” Without electronic media literacy won’t develop hugely and effectively. Therefore, the new era requires individuals to possess some new skills. Considering that students of this new (era), the digital (natives) perform their activities, communication and information management through new communication and information technologies (Åžahin, 2009), identifying the skills required to use these technologies and managing their development are of high importance (Livingstone, 2003). “Menou (2002) suggests that people should be able to use stand-alone computers, computer networks, and primarily, the internet and other applications such as word processor, spread sheet, electronic mail, and possibly more advanced ones such as presentations, production of web pages, (development) of websites, use of digital multimedia equipment and (programs.)” This relates literacy to electronic media, because individuals need to have basic skills to be able to use some of these enhanced features and programs.
​
Counter Argument of our motion
On the other hand, several students prefer print books, and writing notes. For example, my friends Sami and John always take notes and hate to use technology because they think E books are not accurate. For example, anyone can put fake information in the internet, while in print books we can ask the librarian for more information about the book before purchasing it. “our skills in critical thinking and analysis have declined by Patricia Greenfield, UCLA distinguished professor of psychology and director of the Children's Digital Media Center, Los Angeles (Wolpert, 2009)”. Furthermore, some students use their phones and get distracted while the professors and teachers are teaching. Furthermore, in print media we can buy the newspaper and all information have sources or authors. While in electronic media some websites are fraud, not real, and some websites don’t contain authors, and are not credible, in addition they can’t be used in a solid research.
​
Conclusion
At the end technology is connected with media literacy “Media literacy, information literacy and digital literacy are the three most prevailing concepts that focus on a critical approach towards media messages (Tibor Koltay, 2011).” Furthermore, without technology we can’t see our beloved ones who are separated from us. Technology made us literate because we can see, talk, and use body language when we make a video call. People learn many words, ideas, and phrases when they see cartoons on devices, for example. They can learn several languages too. Several scholars believe that technology made the world a much smaller entity. The world became better, we have feedbacks, and surveys that can be taken online we don’t need to visit each individual and ask him, we can just send it through any platform, and we will have several respondents and feedbacks. According to Slater 2007 theory called reinforcing spiral theory we as individuals and media users predict what’s on media, for example when I open the BBC Arabic, I know that they focus on Arabic news, ideologies, and programs, and language, and identity. So, if we are interested in the Arab related ideas and topics, we will be active viewers of this BBC Arabic Channel. The outcome of this channel is mainly focusing on the Arab World, and most viewers are from the Arab world because it talks mainly about them and their issues.